Skip to content

Stop asking disabled people ‘What’s wrong?’: The 3 Ps

Ask any disabled person what want they from non-disabled people, and you’ll hear the same answer: “Stop asking about my diagnosis”.

It’s a simple thing you can do to show solidarity with disabled people. If you need to know their access needs, ask them about their access needs, not their diagnosis.

People asking about diagnoses might be trying to help, might be making small talk, or might just be curious. Your intentions might be good – so why exactly shouldn’t you ask people this question?

This blog gives 3 main reasons. If you enjoy alliteration as much as I do, you can remember them as the 3 Ps: privacy, power, and privilege.

Privacy: Someone’s diagnosis is none of your business

The first reason is straightforward: it’s private medical information that is none of your business. You shouldn’t ask people about things like that just because you’re curious.

There are all kinds of reasons someone might be uncomfortable sharing their diagnosis.

For example:

  • There might be a lot of traumatic memories associated with the diagnosis.
  • Social stigma can make people can look at you differently when you tell them about a diagnosis
  • Other people often have specific expectations of what a certain diagnosis should mean. Some people disclose a diagnosis only to have a random stranger question it, because they don’t fit that person’s idea of what the condition looks like.

All of this is exhausting to go through. If you need small talk, there’s always the weather.

Power: A diagnosis doesn’t tell you what someone needs

But what if you need to know someone’s diagnosis so you can help them?

In fact, the useful information isn’t someone’s diagnosis, it’s their access needs. A diagnosis by itself rarely tells you exactly what the person needs.

For example. if I tell someone I have CRPS, in most cases people don’t even know what that means. But if I tell them I need wheelchair access, they might be able to help.

An educated guess is still a guess

Even for more well-known conditions, you can only guess at how you could help someone based only on their diagnosis.

For example:

  • If you know someone is autistic, you can guess that an event in a loud, busy space might be difficult for them.
  • If you know someone is Deaf, then they you can guess that attending a conference might be difficult for them.
  • If you know someone has cerebral palsy, you can guess that walking around might be difficult for them.

While it’s great to have broad awareness of these kinds of conditions, guesses like this are useless for actually helping an individual. 

Guessing people’s needs removes their power

The problem with guesses like this is that you always need to ask follow-up questions: Would you rather attend an event online? Do you need access to a quiet space? What’s your preferred communication method? Do you use mobility equipment?

If you want to help someone, these are the answers you need. The diagnosis is not the point.

I’ve heard countless stories about people deciding on, and implementing, a solution that they think will help a disabled person, rather than just asking the person what they actually need.

When you do this, it removes autonomy from disabled people and reinforces the message that decision-making power is best held by non-disabled people.

You can skip all of this by just asking everyone what their access needs are.

Privilege: Diagnoses are hard to get

Lastly, we need to talk about what a privilege it is to get a diagnosis.

Only 17% of disabled people were diagnosed at birth. For most disabled people, they either develop or become aware of symptoms later on, and so need to seek out medical care and diagnosis.

That means that 83% of disabled people had access needs before they had a diagnosis.

The long process of diagnosis

Even once someone seeks a diagnosis, it’s not that simple.

In the UK, the first step is for a GP to refer you to the right specialist. Once you pass this hurdle, some waiting lists are years long, particularly for conditions around mental health or neurodivergence. If you have overlapping symptoms, or more than one condition, it becomes harder again.

Autism diagnosis wait times hit 300 days | BBC news

Medical bias

Then there’s the systemic bias within the medical system, which means it’s much harder for some groups to get a diagnosis.

For example, studies consistently show that it’s harder to get a diagnosis if you’re a woman, or a person of colour. Sometimes that’s because their symptoms present differently; sometimes they’re just not taken as seriously.

Women less likely to receive a disease diagnosis than men | Healio

Racial, ethnic, and sociodemographic disparities in diagnosis of children with autism | PubMed

Some people are lucky enough to afford a private diagnosis, but even then, the NHS won’t always accept it.

Self-diagnosis

As a side note, this is why self-diagnosis is valid. Because it’s so hard to get a medical diagnosis, many people self diagnose for certain conditions, particularly for things like autism and ADHD.

Being self diagnosed doesn’t mean you’ve given yourself a label after watching a couple of social media posts. People who self diagnose as neurodivergent have spent a considerable amount of time finding out about the barriers they face and how those fit into a certain diagnosis. It’s important to believe people when they tell you they are neurodivergent, regardless of how they were diagnosed.

We can circumvent all of this by asking people about access needs, not diagnoses.

Ask disabled people the right questions

If you really want to help a disabled person, you could violate their privacy by asking for a diagnosis they might not even have yet, then use that information to decide on their behalf what their access needs are.

But it’s easier and more dignified for everyone if you skip all that and just ask them what their access needs are.