Skip to content

Holistic accessibility: Watch the video

A service can have well designed accessibility in almost all the details, but without taking a look at the bigger picture, it can still be unusable.

Watch the video

Transcript

Can you spot the accessibility issue with this control panel?

I was out and about recently and I was in a public toilet – in an accessible toilet and I came across this control panel.

I’ll just describe it to you a little bit for anyone who’s not able to see it. It’s a nice big control panel and it’s got buttons: ‘Push to lock: door must be closed first’ and then a ‘push to open’ button.

This is great. The text on it is actually really clearly contrasted to black text with a kind of a light grey background. It’s also raised text so there’s a tactile experience there. And there is also braille So being able to choose between those two is great because not all blind people can read braille. So that’s brilliant.

It’s nice and big. The buttons themselves are really big and really easy to press There’s a light for locked and a light for unlocked. And they do use colour. The red light, the locked light, is red, and the unlocked light is green.

Now, there’s absolutely nothing wrong with using colour to convey meaning. In fact, it can often be really useful to use colour to convey meaning because it’s a really quick and accessible way of doing things. The important thing is to not rely on colour to convey meaning and this doesn’t because the lights for locked and the lights for unlocked are in two different places.

So even if you can’t see that one is red and one is green then you can still see the status just based on where the lights are. But then if you can see those colours it’s a bit of a shorthand you should be able to see it Fantastic.

The toilet itself was fairly accessible. It wasn’t a Changing Places toilet but it was, you know ,there was room to manoeuvre it hadn’t been blocked with bins or anything like that. Brilliant.
However I couldn’t use this toilet.

So we’re going to just…I read over really quickly what the button said because I want to focus now really on what they say.

‘Push to lock’ is the first big button. It says underneath ‘door must be closed first’ And then there’s the status for locked and unlocked and then ‘push to open’.

So here’s the question: How do you close the door?

It wasn’t manually closed. Well, I certainly couldn’t manually close it. I stood staring at this for ages. The other side there’s a button to open the door.

I had to go outside and I had to leave my wheelchair and my wife and I had to go in to the non-accessible toilet because I couldn’t work out how to close the door.

So I’m just sharing this as a really interesting example of where you can really think something through. You can design some really great technicalities in terms of not relying on colour in terms of braille, all that kind of thing.

But if the thing that you’re doing cannot be used then it’s not accessible.