My local Morrisons rearranged its trolleys. I can only think that the they’ve done this to maximise the ‘red route’ through the store. Here’s why that was a bad idea.
What they did
Previously, the wheelchair trolleys were placed immediately as you came into the store. They’ve now moved them to a spot at the end of the checkouts, and near the customer service/magazine kiosk area.
Why they did it
I can follow the logic here:
- Most customers don’t use the wheelchair trolleys. There are only 2 available. Most of the time, neither are being used.
- So for the huge majority of customers, having the wheelchair trolleys near the front of the store does not make sense.
- Let’s optimise for the majority, and move those lesser-used trolleys out of the way.
But in practice, here’s what that means for wheelchair users:
You enter the shop and immediately have to turn against the direction of traffic. Everyone coming out of the checkouts is bumping into you – often literally. Other people are stationary, queuing for lottery tickets or querying their receipt. Your challenge is to get a wheelchair trolley – which involves quite a big turning circle – without wheeling over a small child or assaulting an old lady.
Then you have to turn around and go back the way you came in so you can actually enter the grocery aisles.
Shifting the burden
This places a disproportionate burden onto disabled people. It optimises the experience of the majority of shoppers in an infinitesimal way they probably won’t even notice. In return, wheelchair users have a more difficult experience, and are put at a higher risk.
But this isn’t just about Morrisons. We see this all the time online, too.
“Colour blind or sight impaired people won’t be able to read this content. But most people aren’t sight impaired, and that majority will think it’s a much more dynamic color palette.”
“Deaf people won’t know what’s being said in this video. But most people aren’t deaf, and they might find it less engaging with readable captions.”
“Our accessibility page is absolutely crucial if disabled people want to come to our venue. But most people aren’t disabled, so we’ll hide the link to it in the footer, so it’s not distracting.”
It’s all doing the same thing – making content as shiny and engaging as possible for non-disabled people, by putting all of the pain points onto disabled people.
This is a classic definition of ableism.
Stop it
I should probably make a final point about how much money people are losing by excluding people and making them carry that burden. How a good designer is absolutely capable of making a website that is both beautiful and accessible.
But all I really want to say is: please stop doing this. We’re tired.
Get in touch
If you want some advice on how to stop shifting the burden onto disable people, or just want to chat about creating accessible and inclusive experiences, you can get in touch via email.