Creating inclusive content design policies is harder than it looks. You need to protect your reputation, your users, and your workers.
Writing policies – where to start
At the end of last year, Scottish children’s production company Visible Fictions got in touch. They were looking for help with their social media policy.
My first answer when I’m asked to get involved in writing policies and documentation is that we need to start with a workshop. Coming in as a consultant and writing a policy destined to sit in a folder somewhere is a waste of everyone’s time, energy and money.
Asking the right questions
This kind of workshop needs to bring together all the different stakeholders. That means all the people the policy affects, whether they are setting it, are following it, or are the subject of discussions.
By looking at the main issues in a workshop, we can at least work out what questions a policy needs to answer. Hopefully we can answer some of those questions, too. But the answers will always be wrong if the questions are wrong.
Documenting discussions
After the Visible Fictions workshop, the team already felt they had got a lot out of it. They had clearer understanding of where the complex issues were. That’s an important outcome. A policy like this should be a documentation and record of what people have discussed. And it should be under continuous review.
So although I wrote up a draft policy after the workshop, I don’t consider this to be the main work of a project like this. The work is to open up the right discussions, so there are useful decisions to record.
When I refer to the policy in this blog, I use the term ‘working policy’. I don’t use the word ‘final’ because I don’t believe these policies are ever final.
Social media policy aims
Our starting point in the Visible Fictions social media workshop was to come up with a policy that:
- allows them to make the most of social media opportunities
- protects their brand and reputation – as a children’s company, this includes safeguarding young audiences
- keeps social media as a psychologically safe place for everyone using it
These aims already go far beyond voice and tone issues that many social media policies stop at. Yes, it needs to have the brand voice behind it. But the organisation also has a duty of care towards its workers. These might be employees, freelancers, and volunteers.
The central question to address is:
How can workers make the best use of social media in a way that helps the company but doesn’t cause psychological harm?
Types of users and levels of responsibility
Arts organisations tend to use a varying pool of freelancers. Writers, performers, technical staff, venue staff – the list goes on. In an ideal world, you want all these people to be shouting out about your work in a positive way.
But you can’t possibly ask them all to do that in compliance with your brand guidelines. Where do the organisation’s responsibilities end?
We came up with 3 distinct sets of user scenarios.
1. Direct users
Direct users are workers using official channels on behalf of the organisation. This is in some ways the most straightforward group. They have a direct relationship with the organisation. There is also a two-way contractual relationship in place.
2. Indirect users
This means staff and associates using their own channels.
Even within this, there are direct and indirect ways that they can be saying things about the company.
- Direct: For example, sharing a post about an upcoming show on their personal social media.
- Indirect: For example, posting a picture of themselves wearing organisational branding.
3. The wider community
The final group is partners, media, and the general public using social media to discuss the work of the organisation.
Not even the best social media policy in the world can control what this last group has to say. So the working policy covers this group with a simple statement:
“Social media is an infinite ecosystem, and we cannot control where our content is being shared and commented on by people who are not directly associated with us.
If we become aware of inaccurate information being spread about our work, we will make best endeavours to politely refute claims, or where relevant to report posts.
However, we acknowledge that it is in the most part impossible to influence this larger conversation.”
Addressing the difficult questions
Once some of the questions become clear, a workshop is a great chance to dig into some of the more complicated scenarios of policy rules. In particular, this means looking at:
- the boundaries of a rule
- the consequences of breaking it
It’s particularly useful to stress-test some of the vaguer rules that tend to make it into this kind of policy. For example, I’ve seen lots of social media policies that say they don’t want to be political. But our every action is political. Even political neutrality is a political standpoint.
Even when we narrow the definition to ‘party political’, it’s not that simple. Does that mean never following someone with political connections? If the First Minister compliments your work, do you block them?
Guiding examples
It’s not possible to draw a clear boundary for this kind of issue. But the working policy we came up with gives some examples to help guide people.
We might express support for refugee children in Scotland
- We never directly criticise the party responsible for policies
We might express concern in arts funding cuts
- We never criticise specific funding decisions
We might share a post from a politician or political activist praising our work
- We never link this praise to their political party or cause
We might wish people a happy Christmas, Eid, or Hannukah
- We never express personal religious views or criticise religious views
Of course, even these examples have a disclaimer:
“There may be exceptions to the above where our work specifically addresses certain issues. These will be addressed and discussed as relevant.”
But having a policy that exposes and acknowledges this complexity gives a useful starting point.
Protecting workers
As anyone living with any kind of marginalised identity will know, spending time on social media is risky. It is rife with bots, trolls and bigots. Many are looking for any excuse to tell you they disagree with your basic existence. No-one should have to deal with that when they come to work.
So what’s the answer?
The straightforward bit was to make it clear that no-one has to engage with social media if it’s not in their job description. People might be asked to help share posts and spread positive messages, but they are completely free to set their own boundaries.
When the social media ecosystem is your workplace
If social media is what you’re hired to do, it’s never going to be possible to be completely protected from its harmful effects.
Empowerment to block troll accounts only goes some way to helping. Especially given the systemic nature of oppression in our society.
The working policy tells people the first thing to do when you find upsetting content: walk away. Shut down the screen, take some time, and then talk to a manager about it.
The next best steps need to come out of that discussion. It might mean:
- Taking a break from social media for a period of time, for example if there is a current news story that is causing waves of negativity.
- Agreeing to shut down a certain channel or leave a particular group, if its content or moderation has become too upsetting.
- Agreed blocking of certain accounts, channels or hashtags.
Again, the important things here are that the policy:
- acknowledges that this is an issue
- gives a clear starting point
Documenting the answers
I’d love to finish by telling you that the final policy definitively answered all these questions and came up with perfect solutions.
Sadly, the world is messy and complex. The job of codifying human communications is difficult and ever-changing. There are no perfect solutions.
What we did achieve was the important work of:
- unearthing the questions
- exposing the complexity to all the different stakeholders
- helping Visible Fictions to centre safeguarding of both their staff and their young audiences.
Need help with your policy?
If you’d like help or advice creating inclusive content policies, get in touch for a chat.